PCA Archives
Reuben A. Hill was born November
5, 1839, in Naples, Cumberland County,
Maine. He was the son of John Hill and
Rebecca Garland, farmers in the area.
Farming did not seem to be in Reuben’s future, however. By 1860, he was already in San Francisco,
California, working as a common laborer.
That changed with the outbreak of the Civil War, when
Reuben Hill enlisted in the Union Army for a term of three years. On September 29, 1861, he mustered in at Camp
Downey, near Oakland, California, as a third corporal in Co. I, 1st California
Infantry.
As part of the California Column commanded by Colonel
James H. Carleton, Hill’s unit was posted to the New Mexico Territory, where it
saw action against the Confederates at Picacho Peak, Arizona. Hill seems to have been an effective
soldier. He was promoted to sergeant and
then commissioned a captain in Co. K, 1st New Mexico Volunteers (New), at Fort
Sumner, New Mexico Territory, Feb. 29, 1864.
Captain Hill resigned at Fort Union, New Mexico Territory, on February
6, 1866.
After the war, Hill returned to Maine where he married
Vesta Marhon Whittier on January 19, 1865, presumably while on leave from his
military duties. They remained married
until January 1880, when Reuben divorced Vesta so that he could marry a widow,
Jane Tyler Burrell Wilson.
Jane later alleged that Hill drank excessively and was
abusive. By the time he moved out in
1894, he had spent all of Jane’s money.
Destitute, Jane was forced to move in with her married daughter. Although Hill suggested that Jane divorce
him, she did not do so—possibly because of the social stigma of being a
divorced woman.
Reuben Hill then secured a loan from another widow,
Olivia S. W. Payne, with which he purchased a hotel in Strafford, New
Hampshire. He remained in New Hampshire
until about 1902, when he sold the hotel and moved to Arizona to speculate in
mines. Once in Phoenix, Hill was cagey
about his past and intimated that he had traveled in Europe on a mission for
the U. S. government’s secret service.
On December 7, 1905, Reuben Hill died of a broken neck
when thrown from his wagon near his mining property at Cave Creek, Arizona
Territory. He was buried in Rosedale Cemetery,
North section, Block 168, Grave 7.
Hill’s widow Jane did not learn of his death until her
son-in-law saw a notice published in a Boston newspaper. Since she was still legally married to Hill
at the time of his death, she applied for and received a widow’s pension based
on his Civil War service.
-by the Pioneers’ Cemetery Association, Inc.